As Nintendo and Pocketpair’s legal clash over Palworld continues without resolution, new developments emerge regarding contested intellectual property claims. Per Games Fray, U.S. Patent Office director John A. Squires has ordered a formal review of Nintendo’s controversial patent 12,403,397—a move legal analysts describe as notably uncommon.
The patent in question, central to allegations of gameplay mechanics infringement, previously drew criticism from IP attorney Kirk Sigmon, who labeled its approval as “fundamentally problematic from inception.” This re-evaluation process could potentially invalidate the intellectual property claim, dealing a significant blow to Nintendo’s litigation strategy.
Games Fray’s analysis highlights the rarity of such director-initiated reviews, suggesting heightened scrutiny influenced by the case’s public profile. While outcomes remain uncertain, this procedural step indicates potential vulnerabilities in Nintendo’s position. Legal observers note the company’s recent maneuvers, including expansive patent assertions, appear increasingly tenuous.
Should the USPTO revoke this patent, it would undermine a key pillar of Nintendo’s complaint. Though litigation timelines remain lengthy, momentum appears to favor Pocketpair’s defense team as regulatory bodies question the validity of foundational claims in this high-stakes IP dispute.
Stay informed via Wccftech’s Google updates for ongoing coverage of this developing story.
