Could Elden Ring Nightreign be FromSoftware’s most contentious release within the Souls series? The starkly varied player responses have certainly made our recent community survey noteworthy.

Arriving on PS5 recently, Nightreign (a title we frequently misspell ourselves) prioritizes team-based combat, enabling groups of three players – companions or anonymous allies – to battle escalating threats across fragments of the Lands Between.

Fan reactions span extremes: some champion it as an innovative multiplayer experience while others criticize perceived lack of depth. Debate also persists regarding the studio’s experimentation with ongoing service elements.

Our analysis awarded it a ‘great’ 8/10, labeling it “a very interesting game that’s likely going to divide FromSoftware fans.” This assessment rings true given opposing viewpoints.

“While clearly not matching the legacy of flagship entries like Dark Souls 3, Nightreign carves its niche through chaotic fun with allies, demonstrating the developers’ willingness to explore fresh territory,” summarized our evaluation.