After defeating Lumacchio in the Lies of P: Overture DLC, players face a defining choice: execute him or spare his life. Many hesitate, uncertain if this decision impacts rewards, story outcomes, or endings. Here’s what you need to know:
- No gameplay consequences: Neither option affects gear, endings, or unlocks.
- Pure roleplay: The choice reflects your character’s moral stance, not hidden mechanics.
Consequences of Punishing Lumacchio
- A brief cutscene shows his execution, followed by the “You feel warmer” message
- Immediate access to the nearby Stargazer (checkpoint)
- No bonuses: No weapons, items, or alternate story paths
Consequences of Sparing Lumacchio
- Lumacchio curses you but doesn’t retaliate
- Same warmth message and Stargazer access
- Hidden lore: Return post-battle to find a letter where he:
- Accuses you of hypocrisy
- Claims you’re “no better than him”
- Hints at future moral dilemmas
Which Choice is Better?
- Speedrun-friendly: Killing him skips the optional letter retrieval.
- Lore enthusiasts: Sparing him adds narrative texture, though no mechanical advantage.
The decision ultimately hinges on whether you prioritize efficiency or story immersion.
FAQ
Q: Do you get unique loot for either choice?
No. Weapons, gear, and upgrades remain unchanged.
Q: Does sparing Lumacchio unlock secret endings?
No. Endings are unaffected by this decision.
Q: Is humanity tracked secretly?
The DLC has no hidden morality system.
Read More: All Bosses in Lies of P: Overture DLC